Feeds:
Posts
Comments

For Future Doctors: General Misconception of being a doctor PART 1

Over the last few months, many budding doctors have contacted me to ask about the future prospects of doing medicine. Of course I gave them a depressing night after informing them of the current and future prospects of doctors in Malaysia. During these discussions I realise that many of these people do not understand a lot of issues surrounding the field of medicine. Thus I was obliged to write this article to wake up these people from their dream of “guaranteed” life if you were to become a doctor!

1)      Guaranteed Job and Good salary/can make money

Many parents still believe that being a doctor guarantee their children’s future. Well, it may be so before but not in another 5-10 years time. You can read about these issues in my MMA articles column. 20 years ago we only had 3 medical schools producing about 400 doctors a year but now we have almost 30 medical schools in the country (the highest per capita population in the world). Last year alone, almost 4000 new doctors started housemanship in Ministry of Health (MOH). The number will further increase in coming years when all the medical schools start to produce their graduates. I believe it will reach a figure of 6000/year by 2015.

This is where issues arise. Even now, the MOH is struggling to place these doctors in various hospitals in the country. We have almost 30-40 houseofficers in each department now not knowing what to do every day. Their training is compromised and they are being released after that without proper training with license to kill! I may sound negative but this is the reality. Even district hospitals are being used to train houseofficers now, starting 2010. As you would have read in the papers recently of parents complaining that their child has been transferred to East Malaysia after completing housemanship, it is a known fact that the shortage of doctors at this point of time is in East Malaysia. As our MOH Director General had said, most doctors will be sent to Sabah and Sarawak from this year on wards.

What’s going to happen in the next few years? Again, my prediction is, there will be surplus of doctors by 2015. There will more bodies than post in MOH by 2015. Doctors most likely will need to queue up to be posted in government service.  You will be sent to rural and East Malaysia to serve. Any appeal will not be entertained. If you think this would not happen, please look at the nurses! 5 years ago, the government began to approve numerous nursing colleges due to shortage of nurses. Now, we have surplus of nurses without any jobs. I know of nurses who are currently working in petrol stations! BTW, the MOH is currently considering introducing common entry exams for all medical graduates. Only those who pass this exam will be given housemanship post. This will happen soon.

Furthermore there may be a pay cut for doctors when all the post are filled. One of the allowance known as critical allowance of RM 750 will be removed once all the posts are filled. Critical allowance is never a fixed allowance and is usually reviewed every 3 years. As you know, the pharmacist’s critical allowance is going to be removed if not already.

I had one budding doctor who said that the reason she wanted to do medicine is because it is the only field where you have a guaranteed job and a starting salary of RM 6000. Well, I have talked about guaranteed job issue above but she is definitely wrong in stating that the starting salary. The starting salary of HO has gone up over the last 5 years; no doubt about it (please read my MMA article). However, the starting salary of HO currently is about RM 3500 to about RM4000 after including the on-call allowance. Remember, your salary only increases about RM 70/year. You will only reach a salary of RM 6000 after 7 years of service as a medical officer, when you are promoted to U48 according to current promotional prospect in civil service introduced end of last year! BTW, other than the difference of critical allowance, a doctor’s salary is only RM 200 more than a pharmacist in civil service!

2)      Medical degree recognition

 If I can’t work in Malaysia, I can go to Singapore or Australia to work, right?

Again, another misconception. Many do not know that medicine is a very peculiar field and cannot be compared to any other profession. In order for you to work in another country, your degree needs to be recognised by the Medical Council of the other country. If it is not recognised, you would not be able to work there. For your information, only UKM and UM degrees are recognised in Singapore. If it is not recognised, you need to sit and pass the qualification exams in the respective country with no guarantee of a job.

Almost all medical degrees from Malaysia are NOT recognised elsewhere. Malaysia Boleh mah! Only Monash University Malaysia’s medical degree is recognised by Australian Medical Council and thus you would be able to work in Australia/New Zealand. Some of the private medical colleges do twinning programmes with external universities from Ireland/UK/India etc. These may be recognised depending on which degree and where you graduate from.

3)      Housemanship & Compulsory service

I have mentioned a little about housemanship above. As you know the housemanship has been extended to 2 years since 2008. Even though it is good for your own training but it does prolong your future postgraduate training. After Housemanship you have to undergo another 2 years of compulsory service before you decide to resign for private practise or pursue your postgraduate degree. It is during this compulsory service that you will be posted to anywhere in the country.

Furthermore, housemanship is not an easy posting. Even though the numbers of HOs have increased tremendously over the last 2 years, it is still a very exhausting job. Many have had a mental breakdown during housemanship. I just heard of a houseman who is on psychiatric MC for the last 2 months! It seems she thought that being a doctor is just like sitting in a clinic and seeing cold cases (probably she thought she can become a GP immediately!)

4)      Hard work and post graduate training

20-30 years ago, being an MBBS holder itself is good enough. You can easily open a clinic and become a GP and well respected by the community. But things are changing. Even GP practise is a speciality by itself in many countries (Master in Family Medicine/FRACGP etc). Malaysia is also moving towards that. Many patients are demanding and would prefer to see a specialist directly nowadays.

Thus it is important that when you join medicine undergraduate degree, please be prepared to continue your education for another 10 years after graduation! In order for you to complete your postgraduate education, it will easily take another 10 years, assuming you pass all your exams in one try! So, don’t assume your education is only 5 years! MBBS do not mean anything now, in fact it is only considered as a diploma!

Getting into postgraduate training is also becoming increasing difficult. The number of places for Master’s programme is very much limited in local universities. The demand is greater than supply and of course don’ forget the quota system as well! Other than MRCP (UK) – internal medicine, MRCPCH (UK) – paediatric and MRCOG – Obstetric, you have to depend on local master’s programme for your speciality. Thus, you have a very limited option. With such a big number of doctors coming into the market now, I can assure you that getting a place for post graduate education is going to be a major problem in 2-3 years time! Be prepared.

TO BE CONTINUED………………………….

What Hishamudin Rais said below is exactly what I said to one my friend who is an old harden supporter of UMNO but she was still very sentimental to UMNO! Many people especially the older generation still supports UMNO just because of this “Malay right” protector crap. But what they don’t realise is the fact that UMNO has been cheating them all this while, especially since the 1980s. Mahathir screwed up UMNO since then. It is not the same UMNO that was in existence during independence.

 
Hisham Rais: Umno has shrunk the Malay mind
//
Joseph Sipalan
Sep 7, 10
1:23pm
Share 35

Renegade artist Hishamuddin Rais declared that the Malay mind has been “bonsified” (shrunk and distorted, like a bonsai plant) by Umno’s political agenda in order to perpetuate the culture of fear against non-Malays.

The former ISA detainee said that it is typical of Umno to play on racial fears to convince the public that they are the best option for Malays to remain at the forefront of social and economic development in Malaysia.

NONE“This process that ‘bonsifies’, nullifies and stupefies (Malays) goes back to the British time. (Malays) are led by lazy leaders and lazy thinkers,” Hishamuddin (middle in photo) said at the ‘Malays are muted too!’ forum at the KL and Selangor Chinese Assembly Hall last night.

The controversial activist noted that Malays have been indoctrinated to fear new ideas and ‘ghosts’ of Chinese supremacy, to the point that the Malay public believe that the ‘ghosts’ are real threats to their existence.

Taking the example of bomoh or witchdoctors, Hishamuddin claimed that Umno employs the same tactics to convince the Malays that they are constantly battling against hantu (ghosts).

“In Malaysia it is very simple. The hantu for the Malays are the Chinese. The Malays are made to believe that there are all sorts of hantu, to encourage the public to be thankful for Umno (to save them).

“It’s just like (the tactics of) the bomoh in the kampung, where kampung folk will be told that there are all sorts of hantu to deal with… Umno uses the same modus operandi,” he said.

Playing up fears

Hishamuddin claimed that just like the colonial British in Malaya, Umno realises that a liberated Malay mind is a threat to their existence, hence the ruling party’s efforts to stop the liberalisation of the Malay mindset.

He alleged that Umno would never agree to free the Malay mind as it is all about maintaining the ruling party’s power and control over Malaysia’s wealth.

NONEHishamuddin noted that such fear of losing power has only taken hold fairly recently, evident especially in the ruling government’s efforts to perpetuate the fear of a recurrence of the May 13, 1969 racial riots.

“They put the fear in Malays that the Chinese wanted to take over the country. I thought that (notion) was mad, because this is the most mismanaged country, with corruption in the police and the judiciary.

“Because the country is so mismanaged, do you really think the Chinese want to take over the country?” he quipped.

Speaking to an audience of around 160 people, Hishamuddin stressed that the ruling government is simply working on the premise of “manufactured consent”‘, where it employs public institutions such as the Malayan Sultanate to force people to agree with whatever opinions or policies it makes.

He said that it has perpetuated the culture of ‘lazy thinkers’ among Malays, where the best minds end up being unwilling or unable to contribute to the community’s advancement.

Licence just to laugh

Hishamuddin stressed that it is unfortunate that the best Malay minds have been left out of the nation’s education system, to make way for ‘half-educated’ Malays who are bent on maintaining the status quo.

“Malays have become very lazy thinkers. To the non-Malays, I ask that you have sympathy as the Malays are faced with a situation where their reading material is very limited and (the government) allows less and less people (to form their own opinions),” he said.

NONETaking the example of the recent banning of comics by cartoonist Zulkiflee Anwar Ulhaque, better known as Zunar (right), Hishamuddin said it is ridiculous that public expression, particularly by Malay artists, should be censored.

“Just imagine, just to laugh you need to get a licence… and if you want a licence you will have to engage in corruption to pay the Marxists,” he said. 

The article below was written by Dr David Quek, President of MMA in The Malaysian Insider. He is spot on the issues that are happening in this country.

Just before I read David Quek’s article, a friend of mine wrote some interesting comments on my earlier post (Racism/Quality & Transfers) linked to my Facebook. I do agree with him that there are more and more youngsters who can’t speak Malay in our country. Majority of these people are from the Chinese ethnic group. Most of these people are below the age of 20 years old. As a doctor I do see them in my clinic. At times it is rather amusing because the parents can speak good Malay/English but the children can’t. This is a peculiar scenario that we are seeing now. Why is this happening?

Again, we need to go back and see what happened 20 years ago that has progressed to this stage. Way back in the 1960s and 1970s, many vernacular schools were on the verge of being closed down due to lack of enrolments. Many non-Malays felt that they need to go to the National Schools to be part of the country they called home. They wanted to learn Malay, English and mingle around with other races. At that time, the syllabus was still UK-based and was in English but was slowly changed to Malay by end of 1970s. Majority of the teachers were non Malays with the Malay teachers were mainly involved in teaching BM and arts subjects. There were hardly any racial slurs or remarks that were made. All religious societies were freely formed in these schools. The missionary schools were well-respected and was still run by the missionaries with assistance from the government. In fact, most of the school canteens were run by Chinese !! No issue about halal or haram! I was among the lucky ones who just manage to go to National schools at the end of 1970s but then, I realise that something is not right.

Instead of integrating and uniting people under 1 education system, our politicians decided to separate us even further. MARA colleges, boarding schools, ITM(later UITM), matriculation were formed to help the Malays. No doubt that these were necessary to help the poor Malays in the rural area where good schools were not available, in fact there were no secondary schools in a lot of rural areas. But what about poor non-Malays in rural area? they were just left behind! unfortunately what started as a welfare system for the poor rural Malays were soon hijacked by the more urbanised Malays. Slowly, most of the enrolments in these schools were Malays from the urban cities as they were definitely performing better than their rural counterparts. I feel that there is no need for MARA colleges and boarding schools now since we have both primary and secondary schools available in most rural areas nowadays.

After standard 5 exams (equivalent to UPSR today), a lot of my Malay friends disappeared to MARA colleges, agama schools and boarding schools ( one of them supposedly Sheikh Muzaffar, the so-called astronaut). Then came SRP (PMR equivalent) after which the rest of my remaining Malay friends disappeared. So much so, my school (a premier school in Seremban) only had 1 Malay student in the entire Science stream till Form 5! Despite getting good results in SPM, non of the Non-Malays ever received any JPA scholarship!! In fact one of my non-Malay friend(an Indian ethnic) were told directly to his face that JPA scholarship for medical education is only for Bumiputeras, during the interview (back in 1989)! why bother calling for the interview then? His father was just a Tamil school teacher and his mother was a housewife! Talk about social background. At the same time, I can here a lot of my Malay neighbours who got inferior results than me receiving scholarship to go overseas. The worst part, they are better off economically than us!

So we all ended up doing STPM (Form 6) for 2 years to be eligible to enter local universities. And yes, not a single Malay in our school Form 6 science stream. Those who did SPM and got good results were immediately absorbed into matriculation, another BUMI only course! Thank GOD, we did very well in our STPM and got into local university to do medicine. Again, all local universities had quota system not based on merit. Indians were allocated only 16 slots for medicine in UM. Imagine how competitive it was for the non-Malays to enter local university then. Probably that is what that made us better and stronger, survival of the fittest!

Soon, people began to realise that they do not get any benefit by going to national schools and learning BM etc for unity. They are never treated as equals and discriminated in education opportunities. Slowly, they lost interest and started moving away from the national schools thus the mushrooming of vernacular schools again (please read my post on ” 1Malaysia Education” under education page). This coupled with the racial discrimination, racial remarks in schools only made the situation worst. With the introduction of KBSR/KBSM by late eighties, the entire education system was manipulated to benefit the ruling government. History book were revamped and the contribution of non-Malays were wiped out. The students were made to be in cocoons! You can see this with the current quality of university products, which is the extension of our schooling system.

So, talking about patriotism, why should these people be blamed for not able to speak Malay and thus called unpatriotic! As I have always said, we need to look into the root of the problem before making any comments or remarks. If you are at the receiving end, you will know the answer. People have lost faith in this country as the discrimination only seem to be getting worst. Of course, those who have benefited from the system will not know the problems the others are facing. Even though at times I do get angry with people who can’t speak Malay or English, I feel pity for them as circumstances have made them to be like that. Circumstances created by our ruling party, divide and rule policy! Below I attach one of my friend’s comment in my facebook , saying the same as what I have said:

 

but if one were to target just the chinese by quoting “wa tak tahu cakap malayu” … pls be sensitive about this issue. many of the older and some younger generations are not proficient at all with the national language. i can excuse the old generations because some are direct migrants from china and many live amongst themselves being self sufficient. in fact, i can tell u with so many middle man & touts & corrupt tradesmen running around, i can tell u its still good living in this country without knowing the national language well. but does this make them any less malaysian ?

as for the younger generations, many policies in this country have forced the non bumis in this country to give up hope learning the language well. (but that doesnt mean they are any less malaysian than you) Many were educated overseas or private schools or chinese schools where BM were not emphasized at all. why ? because all the local universities are biased against them, all the govt contracts will not be allocated to them, even in nasional schools many are racially ostracized, even the courts have given up the idea of making our bahasa compulsory for ALL documents. and with many middle men serving their needs, there is practically no chance for the non malays to grasp the language well. again, does that make these citizens any less patriotic than you ? (patriotism does not mean can sing national anthem and speak BM … it also involves of many many other factors u know … glorifying racism does not mean one is patriotic)

last but not least. you said many don’t bother to speak malay while staying in this country. actually the truth is, many bother to speak but had no good teachers in school to teach them lah. all languages the same, takes a good while to pick up the language lah. for the extreme ppl who really cant speak anything, those form just a super small minority. its like someone who dont speak english in this part of the earth, i mean english has been the ubiquitous language, why more than half of the ppl on earth cant speak the language well ? does that mean they should go home to outer space or balik hutan where all of us walk out from ?

bahasa melayu is still a very young language. i can say it is one of the easiest language to learn on earth and it can be a beautiful thing to be able to sing songs with it. but by targeting the chinese and saying one is not a malaysian because this person cannot grasp the language is totally wrong. knowing the language is just one of the many factors to call yourself patriotic but it is certainly not the only criteria. besides, even if we were 100% patriotic, will we all be accorded the bumiputera status and be recognized as a true malaysian and enjoy all the benefits of this country ?

this country is currently in a mess from top to bottom, across all boards. sparking controversial debates using the chinese descendents is very very unfair. fyi, i am already the 5th generation of migrant in malaysia, why am i not considered a bumi ? i speak malay, though i am not a muslim, i understand this country and its history, i know my rights, i know the constituition, i know the culture and i know my public holidays, i also know my agong and the sultan, i know all the ministers and i know the national anthem. i also know what merdeka is all about.

lastly, the indonesians. have you met indonesians who cant speak a word of indonesians ? how many indonesians have u befriended all your life ?
?malaysian earlier than any of us ? does that make them any less malaysia who had no idea how to speak BM properly. blame who & blame what ? aint they here in …malaysians and eastern asli have come across many orang i do agree with you many are not proficient in BM. iyes

 

Rising racism, 53 years on

By David KL Quek

This year, I became a senior citizen. I can now withdraw my EPF savings and I qualify for some discounts for travel and surprisingly even for some buffet meals at some eateries.

But as I ponder upon ‘retirement’, it is sad to see the Malaysia that I know and live in, grows increasingly uncertain, diffident and bogged down in self-made crises, one after another.

Our previously phenomenal economic growth has now trickled down in a dizzying spiral of middle-income trap – not helped by the 2008 global financial crisis.

Our foreign direct investments have dwindled as our competitiveness, our productivity, perhaps our systemic corruption and wastage, have now been exposed and called into question.

Even our inborn entrepreneurs are investing overseas because of the uncertain future and shifting policies, which have made us face the truth of our competitiveness and value as a nation.

Instead of maturing gracefully, we appear to have become trapped in a petulant phase of angry adolescence breaking out senselessly to attack convenient bogeymen -race and religion appear to have become the easy targets, which breed even more political and economic uncertainty.

As a fourth generation Malaysian, I was born two and a half years before our fateful Merdeka. I am still wondering whether we are truly ‘liberated’ as befits the meaning of ‘Merdeka’, so gloriously proclaimed by our Bapa Merdeka, Tunku Abdul Rahman Putra Al-Haj, in 1957.

That Merdeka was to have ushered in the birth of what some would have called ‘an unlikely nation’, one that appeared cobbled together in a slapdash manner, juxtaposing a disparate if hodgepodge peoples – predominantly Malays, Chinese and Indians- and akin to mixing oil in water. Yet again, does any one in such serendipitous circumstance have that conscious sense of history and historicity of these singular moments?

To be fair, even then, no one dared to dream that the idea of Malaya and later Malaysia could succeed. But truth be told, we did do very well for so many years, becoming one of the rising ‘Asian tigers’. It’s just these recent years that we have foundered and perhaps lost a little faith in ourselves.

So many other post-colonial new nations had self-destructed in interethnic, religious or tribalistic clashes and conflagrations. We nearly did in May of 1969.

But good sense and firm actions created a novel social re-engineering feat (the NEP) in its wake, to bring about some semblance of order, reasonable interethnic tolerance and suppressed racial tensions.

For the next four decades, we have lived a reasonably harmonious if distinct existence, although seething fault-lines appear now and again to threaten the veneer of our touted ‘Truly Asian’ unity among our unique pastiche of colourful normalcy.

Forty years hence, ratcheted-up rhetoric is beginning to sunder this extraordinary relationship. Polarised insistence on continued affirmative action in stylised if arbitrary terms, remains a bone of contention, which powerfully fans the embers of resurgent ethnic fears and pride.

Sadly, as we celebrate this auspicious anniversary, we seemed mired in increasingly rabid and insulting racism, which greatly threatens our flimsy unity and contrasting diversity.

Extremist leaders continue to spew so much hurtful invectives that these would have shamed the most neo-Nazi right-wingers, the world over. Most modern societies would have punished such hate-mongers if not for their senseless racial baiting but then for their ad hominem attacks on just about anyone who dares to challenge their warped if narrow worldview.

Perhaps the media can play their roles better by downplaying these media hounds, whose purposes are so sickening and depraved.

Racist rhetoric

It appears that more and more politicians are flogging the twisted if populist concept of ethnic supremacy and extraordinary rights (of ethnic ketuanan) once again, as if to bolster their public images as racial champions. The loudest and the most strident appear to be those who are now commanding the greatest publicity and arguably some perverse following.

Our authorities appear timorous in not wanting to directly confront these vociferous bullies, for fear of some unintended backlash. But in so doing, the government loses even more credibility. The government of the people must serve as a fearless just arbiter of a firm and respected Leviathan, and not be held ransom by some mindless minority.

There cannot be distorted applications of the rule of law, where any one can flaunt and challenge the wisdom of the law, at wanton will. There seems to be no more respect for anyone else except for the self-righteous bully pulpit arrogance of voluble tyrants disgorging more and more hatred and painfully shrill racist ideologies to the hilt.

Freedom of speech implies rational discourse and debate, not threatening and insulting rantings. It certainly does not absolve anyone of despicable spewing and inciting of ethnic or religious intimidation or hatred.

But who really is to blame for the recent rise in racist rhetoric?

It appears that some components of the government are still pushing the propaganda machine to perpetuate the concept of racial supremacy and denigrating all other ethnic groups.

The Biro Tata Negara (BTN, National Civics Bureau) instead of instilling national civic consciousness, appears to relish in inculcating and indoctrinating any civil servant or would be scholarship holder, in a time-warped belief system that only the Malays are true patriots and truly deserving of their Malaysianness.

This is still happening 50-odd years following Merdeka, and one wonders why non-bumiputeras don’t sometimes feel any greater sense of belonging to this nation of ours.

Surprisingly such BTN programmes appear to have been a ‘recent’ phenomenon. My sister and brother-in-law who are senior government servants in the Ministries of Education and Higher Education respectively claimed never to have been subject to such gross demeaning indoctrination or abuse – perhaps, they too have been too polite, too programmed, to acknowledge. It did not take place when I was a clinical lecturer for seven years at Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia in the 1980s and early 1990s.

But as MMA president, I have received some angry verbal complaints (many are traumatised, frightened and do not want to be quoted for fear of reprisals) that even non-bumiputera junior medical specialists and house officers, who aspire to join the service or to be confirmed, are currently subject to physical and mental abuse. Mind you, these are not students of impressionable age, but grown men and women in their twenties and thirties.

Some have been made to squat and huddle together in front of other bumiputera peers, rudely woken at early mornings, shouted at, called pendatang, usurpers of scholarships and positions, depriving the true bumiputeras of their places and rights, told in uncertain terms that they are here only at the behest and kindly generosity of the bumiputeras, and that they can always ‘go home’ or balik kampung which means China or India.

Groups have been bullied into subordinating to and acknowledging the official ‘dogma’, or risk having the entire group not ‘passing the course’. Do these utterances ring a bell?

Less than a year and a half ago, one young returning teacher broke down from such radical abuse and hazing, that her family decided to pull her out, repaying the loan in full – enough is enough! So can we not see how this will perpetuate the cycle of blatant racial baiting and hatred when these ‘officers’ return to their respective services, after such provocative BTN courses?

Mustn’t such propaganda stop? Is the government truly sincere in wishing to stem such state-endorsed racism? Is this government truly espousing the 1Malaysia concept for whatever it is worth?

Last year, Minister in the PM’s Department Mohd Nazri Abdul Aziz acknowledged that the BTN must be overhauled. He had revealed that courses by the BTN were racially divisive and used to promote certain government leaders. While Nazri was bold enough to expose this, he was nearly alone in defending the need to overhaul the BTN courses.

Most of the ruling elite, including the deputy premier had sided with those who refused to acknowledge Nazri’s contention that the BTN was a mockery of the 1Malaysia concept. Of course, former premier Dr Mahathir Mohamad joined in and insisted there was no need to revamp the BTN courses, which led Nazri to call the former PM a “bloody racist”, even conferring on Dr M the title “the father of all racists”.

So are we surprised that Perkasa, school teachers and principals, public officers, resort to such ‘ingrained’ behaviour, notwithstanding the so-called ‘provocation ‘ from their charges, their students, who must surely be so ‘insensitive’ as to other’s religious practices?

Pursue the perpetrators

Yet, when called upon to investigate such racist behaviours, the authorities appear to be dragging their feet, and instead concentrate with such efficiency to question and charge a rapper (NameWee) who merely was bold and foolhardy enough to serve as a conduit to expose these wrongdoings.

Can the police and authorities not see the biasness of their actions, by pursuing the messenger and not the perpetrator of possible crimes?

Can the authorities not understand why thinking Malaysians and non-bumiputeas are beginning to feel persecuted and discriminated against, more and more, despite utterances to the contrary by our political leaders?

Can the authorities not understand why more and more disgruntled non-bumiputeas are making a beeline to emigrate whenever and wherever they can – hardship, uprooting displacement and starting over, notwithstanding? This has got nothing to do with patriotism, when one is constantly told that he or she is unequal as a citizen, and that they are unwanted.

Can every Malaysian non-bumiputera truly feel that he or she has a fair and reasonable share of this piece of earth called Malaysia? Do our authorities truly appreciate talent, merit or worth of any non-bumiputera at all, or is this mere lip service? Can they not see the hollowness and insincerity of their pronouncements – when we can hardly see the ‘walk’ from the ‘talk’?

Such crescendos of racist ravings seriously undermine the carefully constructed dream of a true Malaysian nation, shattering the much-bandied ‘unity’ slogan already so tattered among our terribly troubled diversity.

Hurtful cries to demonise and belittle other races as unequal, pendatang and lesser than themselves cannot but help demoralise every peace-loving non-bumiputera Malaysian who aspires for a better tomorrow, a better Malaysia.

We fully recognise the special position of the bumiputeras, but as non-bumiputeras we also increasingly demand our rightful place in this nation of ours. Lest it is forgotten, our position is also enshrined in the constitution. This is not arrogance, but a statement of fact as a human right of any citizen.

We do have a long way to go. We have many mindsets to change, to engage, to dialogue with in sincerity and humility, so that race and religion cannot be made a bogeyman for every travail or challenge that the country is facing.

We have our work cut out for us, but as rational Malaysians, we must all try even harder to persuade the government to be one for all Malaysians and not for mere sloganeering alone or for any one racial group.

We must flush out all closet racists. We must instead cultivate greater rational discourse and dialogue without preconditions of threats and top-down dictates. We need to work on closer cross-ethnic cooperation, tolerance and acceptance so that together we are truly more than the sum of our rich individual strength and heritage.

We must nurture greater cohesiveness by lowering the tempo and temperature of racial baiting and shrill cries and rhetoric of ethnic pride and irrational fear-mongering. We must work towards greater confidence of sharing and building and not engage in divisive dismantling bigotry based on artificial barriers of so-called ethnic or religious sensitivities.

This government must be seen to act without fear or favour, by espousing fair and just policies, by directly confronting and stemming the tide of racism and racial-baiting. Divisive ravings drive uncertainty and suppress confidence. We need to reverse such negative rhetoric if we wish to improve the climate for economic buoyancy in this country.

By staying the course of inept inattention, we stand to lose our global competitiveness even more, as we Malaysians lose confidence in ourselves and our grip on the future.

We must do this right and soon, or risk losing everything! 53 years hence, and Merdeka then would have been in vain.

“We came into the world like brother and brother, And now let’s go hand in hand, not one before another.” – William Shakespeare, in the closing couplet of ‘The Comedy of Errors’ [V.i.425-26]

DR DAVID KL QUEK was the editor-in-chief of the MMA News (bulletin of the Malaysian Medical Association) for 11 years and is currently president of the MMA.

2 weeks ago we had 2 principals asking the non-Malays to go back to their forefather’s country and now we have a police officer who have said the same thing! I wonder where this country is heading to…….. This incident below clearly tells us the standard of English among our civil servants. Basically this police officer do not understand English and asked the complainant to speak in BM. This is a common phenomenon now. I had many teachers who were my patients but were unable to speak English when I explain to them in English. The best part was when I asked them what subject are they teaching in school, answer : Maths/Science!!! Aren’t this subject thought in English!

What happened to the 2 principals? Well, I heard one was transferred to office work and the other is on leave till completion of investigations. Why is it taking so long to take any action against these individuals? In our bloated civil service, it is a common phenomenon that any non-performing staffs are just transferred to another department. He/She receives the same salary but got to do lesser amount of jobs. Subsequently he/she will be promoted as anyone else based on seniority of service rather than performance. This is the reason why our civil service is rotting away, coupled with poor product of our education system.

I just had a retired ex-senior nurse who told me above the misery she has to undergo at a first class ward of a government hospital. Medications not served, no proper nursing and totally no caring attitude from the current generation of nurses! This is not a common findings if you are in a government hospital nowadays, poor quality of nurses. This retired nurse just asked me one question ” This happened to me in a first class ward, i wonder what the patients are undergoing in the 3rd class ward!” . I share the same feelings with her. Imagine, you can become a nurse with just 3 credits in SPM nowadays! What quality do you expect? And it is happening everywhere in our country. That is the reason why the FDI is dropping as we can’t provide enough human resource for any companies who wants to invest in this country. The good and hardworking ones will leave the country as they can’t tolerated these non-sense!

Sunday September 5, 2010

Racism: Cop under probe

By ANDREW SAGAYAM
saggy@thestar.com.my

KUALA LUMPUR: A police inspector who allegedly told a 51-year-old snatch theft victim to “balik China” (return to China) if she could not speak Bahasa Malaysia is being investigated.

City police chief DCP Datuk Muhammad Sabtu Osman said the inspector, in his 30s, was from the Sentul district police headquarters. He is being investigated by the city police headquarters disciplinary committee headed by the Chief Police Officer.

The officer, who is attached to the Criminal Investigation Depart­ment, has been temporarily relieved of his duties pending investigations. He is now handling administrative work.

He allegedly made the remark to housewife Loh See Moi, who was a snatch theft victim on Aug 24 in Kepong.

“The police force will not defend and protect any policemen, if they are guilty of wrongdoing,” said DCP Muhammad Sabtu.

Loh, from Selayang, lodged a police report against the inspector at the Jinjang police station yesterday, alleging that he had uttered these words: “Jika tak tahu cakap Bahasa Melayu, balik China” (go back to China if you can’t speak Bahasa Malaysia).

In her report, Loh said she had gone to the Kepong police station accompanied by her daughter Fong Ay Lian, 26, to lodge a report following the snatchtheft.

She said at the inspector’s office, her daughter spoke to the officer in English but he refused to entertain her as she was not the complainant.

Then as Loh began to relate her ordeal in English, the inspector made the remark.

Loh said she asked him in Bahasa Malaysia why he made the remark, saying that she was a Malaysian.

DCP Muhammad urged the public to lodge a report or complaint with their respective district police chiefs if they encountered problems with policemen or officers.

“I will be very disappointed if the allegations against my officer are true. We will investigate the matter thoroughly,’’ he added.

This X-ray of the Pelvis belongs to a 33-year-old man. He was diagnosed to have Rheumatoid Arthritis 2 years ago but was not managed properly. He was only treated with steroids and pain killers by many doctors. He came to see me with pain over the left hip and inability to walk properly over the last few months. This X-ray shows a severe destruction of the left hip-joint with eroded acetabulum, making the hip-joint to protrude into the pelvis. We call this condition as Petrusio acetabulum.  

I feel sad for this man as nothing much can be done for the damage that has already occurred. A difficult total hip replacement is possible but he is too young for this to be done unless the pain is unbearable.  

Petrusio Acetabulae in Rheumatoid Arthritis
This was an interesting article written by Azmi Sharom in the Star today. Malaysia is probably the only country in the world who still practises institutionalised racism! Quotas everywhere which is not based on needs but based on skin colour and race. Since when Bumi discounts of houses became a Malay right! It is not stated anywhere in the constitution, as what PERKASA claims. Tun Razak introduced this discount scheme to encourage Malays to buy houses, especially in towns but unfortunately, as I said before, anything that is too long is detrimental. Now it has become a Malay right!. Remember, NEP was clearly drafted to last for only 20 years but now it is being hijacked by the Malay elites to benefit them. As what Tony Pua said, why a person who can buy a house worth RM500 000, need a discount? Why a person who earns millions as a director need scholarship for his children?This is what I call total misuse of the system. God is watching!

Stand up and be counted, Malaysia

Brave New World (The Star)
26 August 2010

It is strange that in the 21st century, we are still having to face the problem of institutionalised racism.

______________________________

OVER the past week or so, there have been some developments in our country which are more disturbing than usual.
In particular, the two cases of alleged racist remarks by school heads; the accusations that Penang mosques have replaced the Yang di-Pertuan Agong with the Chief Minister’s name in their prayers; and the continued insistence that Article 153 of the Constitution is equal to an inalienable right that could not be questioned.
These events are interrelated and it seems to me that they indicate that there is a battle of ideology going on in the country now.
On one side is the idea that a person’s ethnicity and religion entitles him to be treated better than anyone else who is different. On the other side is the idea that equality is an aspiration that is both noble and necessary for nation building.
It is strange that in the 21st century we are still having to face the problem of institutionalised racism.
Looking at our history, one can see why this has occurred. The combination of race-based politics and poorly interpreted constitutional provisions have meant that the idea of racial and religious superiority has been allowed to grow and become the norm rather than something undesirable and out of the ordinary.
How else can one explain the possibility that teachers, the very people to whom we entrust the education of our children, can have such warped values and also have the gall to express those views publicly?
How else can we explain the near rabid attack on the Penang Chief Minister for something which he and the state religious department have vehemently denied and in fact would have been insane to attempt?
Let’s analyse this one step at a time. When the dominant political parties in this country do not have any political ideology to speak of and are instead, based on the principle that each race-based component has a duty to safeguard the interest of its community, what one has is a recipe for the kind of policy and rhetoric that divides rather than unites.
Historically, one can see the reasons why the politics of the nation was forged in this way. It was a necessary evil in the face of the divide-and-rule policy by the British to show that even when separate, the three major communities of the nation can still work together politically.
However, it is an unsustainable model and what started life as a fairly rosy example of racial cooperation too easily descended into crude racialist type politics.
Which is why the early aspirations that our founding fathers had for a society treated with equality has now been all but buried by the idea that one race is superior to others and in fact is the only race with any right to be here in Malaysia.
This is because in the battlefields of politics, it is easiest to appeal to base racialist emotions, especially when without those types of ideas, a party based on race will have no collateral to work with.
In this kind of political atmosphere, it is of no surprise that what has been forgotten is that the basis of this nation was one of justice and equality. And the document that is meant to protect that, the Federal Constitution, has been misinterpreted to the extent that there is no longer any trace of this aspiration in the mainstream discourse of the day.
Let us be absolutely clear on this matter, the Constitution does give powers to the government to take affirmative action and it does acknowledge the fact that Islam has a special place in the public life of the nation.
What it does not intend to do however is create a perpetual system of ethnic-based favourable treatment nor does it advocate the idea that all other religious beliefs must be subservient to Islam.
However, instead of this reasonable position, what we have today is the idea that affirmative action for Malays is unquestionable and to be continued in perpetuity becoming the norm.
This cannot be further from the truth as there are no legal justification for it at all.
Article 153 of the Federal Constitution is seen as the holy grail for those who hold this view. However, if we examine the provision closely we will notice two things.
Firstly, affirmative action is not a Malay right. Article 153 does not endow a right. What it does is to merely give government the power to take affirmative action despite the overarching ideal of equality which is enshrined in Article 8 of the Constitution.
To support this contention, we see that Article 8 clearly states that all citizens in this country are equal except for situations specifically provided for in the Constitution. Those “specific provisions” are found in Article 153 and there are not many of them.
They include the power to establish quotas for the civil service, permits and licences, scholarships and education.
Therefore anything other than these areas should not be subjected to affirmative action.
Furthermore, any affirmative action has to be reasonable. The idea of what is reasonable must surely be open to research and debate otherwise there will always be the risk of abuse and wastage of resources.
This being the case, although questioning the existence of such a power to have affirmative action is moot, discussion on the efficacy of affirmative action policies and programmes surely is not.
The way the discourse is today, and not merely by the racialist fringe but by mainstream politicians in power, is that even the implementation of Article 153 is not to be questioned at all.
This is surely wrong based both on the meaning of the Constitution as well as the principle held by the founding fathers that Article 153 was an unfortunate but necessary aberration from the ideals of equality and that it was to be used not in perpetuity.
With these kinds of distortion of law, is it any wonder then that we still get people actually classifying whole swathes of the citizenry as having no right to be here?
Is it any wonder then that a crazy accusation against a Chief Minister whose government has given twice as much money to the Islamic bodies in the state than the previous administration, can give rise to the belief that he is a threat to the faith?
If this country is to have any future as a true nation, the time has come for those who believe in the ideals of equality, ideals which were held by the political founding fathers of the country as well as the traditional Rulers of that time, to stand up and be counted.
To not be cowed by the bigots and to say that this is our country and it stands on noble humanitarian ideals, not opportunistic racialist thinking.

This is an excellent write-up by Mariam Mokhtar(below).

Well, Ibrahim Ali and the UMNO goons have asked the non-Malays to go back wherever they came from. I have said this before, that there will come a time when the population of non-Malays will be less than 10% in Malaysia. I predict this will happen sooner than expected, probably by 2050. I may not be around by that time or probably still around but in some other country, perhaps!
I would love to see where this country will be at that point of time and how the Malays will be cheating their own race and the widening gap of the rich and the poor Malays, which is already happening. 
I just hope the Orang Asli’s will say the same to Ibrahim Ali, Najib Razak,  Ahmad Ismail , the school headmistress etc etc to go back to the Indonesian islands!
 
They screw up this country and keep using the non-Malays as their punching bag to divert the attention. Fighting for Malay rights konon, pooooooooooooooooooodah…………………………
  
Life in the Malay Utopia
//
Mariam Mokhtar
Aug 23, 10
12:59pm

If Tunku Abdul Rahman were alive today, he would weep at the destruction of bridges he had built between the races in Malaysia.

In a speectunku abdul rahmanh to the Foreign Correspondents Association in May 1961, he warned us about “a small minority who did not think, feel, believe and work for the good of Malaya”. Referring to national unity, he said: “This goal would not be achieved if the Chinese continued to think and talk of everything Chinese.”

Ironically, some Malays and a misguided Chinese convert have let the Tunku down, while the non-Malays have embraced his vision wholeheartedly.

The Tunku was passionate about loyalty: “We, who are here, have only our little Malaya. The Chinese, Malays and others have to make the best of our home here. Malaya, our one and only home”. He explained that without unity, “there would be conflict and hell will break loose”.

Fast forward to 2010 and the two school principals who allegedly told their Chinese students to “return to China”. They’ve aped the anti-Chinese rhetoric of Ibrahim Ali, Ahmad Ismail and Ridhuan Tee Abdullah. They are egged-on by a former prime minister, who refuses to retire gracefully, and whose constant meddling will destroy this country. 

barisan nasional rais yatimNot content at being sidelined, Information, Communication and Culture Minister Rais Yatim has condemned the MCA president for demanding the gradual reduction of the 30 percent bumiputera economic equity.

However, let’s forget about 30 percent bumiputera equity.

Let’s imagine a ‘Ketuanan Melayu Utopia’ with 100 percent Malay bumiputera equity, with all the Chinese ‘banished’ to China and the Indians to India.

Will we be socially, economically, morally and religiously content, in Malay brotherhood?

In this Utopia, will the handful of individuals who used to control the wealth of the nation, relinquish their economic stranglehold and share it?

Their actions could eradicate poverty across the country and lift the economic status of the Malays, especially the rural Malays.

But I doubt that they will give up control and power.

Will the government-linked companies or the companies ‘belonging’ to powerful politicians share projects with the other 97 percent of the population? Would projects be put to open tender? Would the Ali Baba companies that used to exist be disbanded? Or will clones of these Ali Baba firms emerge?

Lifestyle changes?

How will our schools fare? Teachers, especially principals, need not go into racist rants. Will bullying and harassment manifest itself in other forms?

Out will go the subject called ‘Moral’ for the non-Malays. Sports, especially for girls, would probably cease; Westernised activities like boy-scouts or girl-guides would stop.

As music is Pakistan imposes syariah law religious school studentsanathema to Muslim teachings, unless they are nasyid songs, students who appreciate music and want to learn a musical instrument would have to stop harbouring foolish ideas.

There will be even less emphasis on English. A nephew at a Mara boarding school tried to improve his English, by speaking English to his friends. Unfortunately, both his schoolmates and teachers teased him, “Kamu-ni action-nya, nak jadi Mat-Salleh kah?” (Why are you showing off, do you want to be a Westerner?) so he stopped.

With universities attended and staffed by Malays only, standards should be expected to rise, because there is no competition to slow them down and distract them.

With this new Ketuanan Melayu Utopia, there will be open season on polygamy. Men will be able to marry whenever and whoever they like. There will be no equality for women.

A man can opt to marry girls as soon as they reach the age of puberty. He can get around the laws prohibiting sex with a minor, by marrying in Malacca. When he tires of her, there is always the option of a second, third or fourth wife.

He need not worry about his children’s welfare, or breakdown of the family-unit, as the courts rarely enforce maintenance payments. Women being responsible mothers, will always work harder, to subsidise his lifestyle and support his family.

Places that used to sell alcohoalcohol banl, and entertainment establishments like nightclubs or karaoke bars, will cease to exist and ‘social ills’ should disappear. The ‘moral police’ who used to look for drinkers like Kartika, may be downsized. Unemployment figures could rise as a result.

Will the khalwat squads still turn a blind eye to immoral VIPs? Having a 100 percent Malay nation will not stop illicit sex.

As there will be no more Gregorian New Year and Valentine’s day celebrations, there will be no more abandoned babies.

How will the Malays decide between employment in the cushy civil service or a job in the private sector? Will the government machinery become leaner and more efficient?

Identity, cultural crises

With religious fervor, will the Malays become fully Arabicised or Islamicised? Our Malay architectural heritage has long been abandoned for Arabic domes.

The kebaya has bmalay muslim islam womeneen usurped by the jubah. Tudung or mini-telekung have replaced ordinary head scarves. Even Malay men parade in white Arab robes. War memorials are banned and logos on football jerseys are subject to scrutiny.

Malay weddings have long since become politically correct and institutionalised. Apart from the customary vulgar display of wealth, there is no more joget or mingling among guests. Men and women have neglected how to behave in each other’s presence because of segregation. Basically, everyone has forgotten how to have fun.

The Malays are suffering from an identity and cultural crisis. They are stuck in a time-warp and refuse to move with the times. They lack a strong leader. They have been held back by leaders who do not understand their needs but who were content to use them indiscriminately. Malays have been conditioned to be suspicious of each other and kept in check by fear.

All the Ibrahim Alis, azlanAhmad Ismails, Ridhuan Tee Abdullahs and racist school-principals of Malaysia are simply ‘dark-skinned’ neo-Nazis. If these ‘pseudo Aryans’ believe that 100 percent bumiputera equity, or banishing non-Malays from Malaysia will improve our social and economic outcomes, then their heads need examination.

When their experiment for a 100 percent Malay nation-state fails to lift the rural Malays out of poverty and creates a wider gap between rich and poor Malays, what then? When their ill-conceived ‘social-engineering’ creates more Malay disunity, who will they blame?

In our Malay Utopia, will Dr Mahathir Mohamad be sent back to Kerala, will Ridhuan Tee be returned to China and will the other ‘Indonesian Malays’ like Dr Mohd Khir Toyo and Najib Abdul Razak be sent packing?

//

 

MARIAM MOKHTAR is a non-conformist traditionalist from Perak, a bucket chemist and an armchair eco-warrior. In ‘real–speak’, this translates into that she comes from Ipoh, values change but respects culture, is a petroleum chemist and also an environmental pollution-control scientist.

 

This is an interesting write-up by AB Sulaiman. Very well written.

No flag-waving on Merdeka Day

//
AB Sulaiman
Aug 19, 10
12:18pm
Share 17

COMMENT August 31st is coming and our leaders are already instigating all of us to show our patriotism, loyalty, love and respect for our beloved nation by way of planting the Jalur Gemilang everywhere – on our car top, roof of our homes and factory or office buildings.

NONEI did not do it last year or the year before.

I am not inclined to do so this year either for I am suffering from a disease known as ‘malangitis’. I just coined this word, so don’t bother looking up the dictionary for its meaning.

It’s from the word malang or bad luck or cursed in Malay. It infers sakit Ketuanan Melayu, thus the cursed Ketuanan Melayu disease. I am having the bad luck of suffering from the excesses of the Ketuanan Melayu leadership as they run the country, so I won’t be in a festive mood come Merdeka Day.

Apparently malangitis took root when the Malay leadership took absolute control over the running of the country after the May 13th 1969 debacle. 

The Malays were like the proverbial hungry fishermen among other not-so-hungry ones.

The leaders meaningfully wanted to preserve the honour and dignity of the Malays by formulating and instituting policies that would catapult the Malays into the not-so-hungry fishermen category; into the Malaysian economic mainstream.

NONESo they did what had been thought a wonderful idea – by giving the Malays a lot of fish. But of course for a limited period of twenty years, according to its architect, the second PM, Abdul Razak Hussein (right).

In other words by 1990 they wanted to see the Malays in control of thirty percent of the Malays from a very low two. We all know the name of the policy is the NEP.

But giving fish to a bunch of hungry fishermen has proven to be a short-sighted way of solving the problem. Better had they been given some materials like wood, some tools like axes, saws, nails, ropes, threads and such and teach them how to make boats and nets. They would soon be able to fish again! It’s a sustainable solution so they won’t be hungry ever again!

This would amount to changing a mindset, of jumping out of the paradigm box.

But changing the mindset is a tough exercise. It requires a good injection of technical knowledge, skill, ability and experience, and quite possibly involves a lot of sacrifice and hard work.

It takes a lot of time too, not to mention good old fashioned luck. More importantly perhaps, it takes a lot of mental attitude to want to jump out of the box, to change, in the first place. A quick fix might provide short term relief to a deep-seated problem but not sustainable long-term ones.
 
Stagnant level

Well, we all know that the targeted twenty years had passed by and Malay involvement in the economy had been, well, lacklustre – at 18.9 percent in 1990 and apparently at this stagnant level in around 2005 by the government’s own admission. I am wondering what the figure is now.

And here came the first symptom of malangitis. In 1990 the leaders did not call the country’s stakeholders (that’s us) in the country to sit down, have a close look and analysis at the situation, and to come up with some fresh ways of going forward.

Had they done so, at this point they might discover the truth that the Malays might have the wish to change but have not got the mental and technical wherewithal, capability, and the courage to undertake painful sacrifices beyond just hard work. Appropriate plans and programmes would have been formulated.

But instead the leaders did not even have the intelligence to seek feedback. They went on doing exactly what they have been doing in the past twenty years: continue with the (already proven) ineffective quick fix. They gave the Malays more and more fish!

Since then and for two decades now, the country went into a tailspin.

Well, well. All modern pundits and philosophers say that we all must learn from our mistakes for if we don’t we are bound to repeat it. And repeat it we have. We are now paying the price for our folly.

For a start democracy has become a dirty word. It used to be the system of government of the people by the people and for the people, but now to a system of government of BN, by Umno and for the Malays.

It used to be a system of rule of law but now it’s rule by law (i.e. for private individuals). It used to be a system where justice and fairness is the norm, and where meritocracy is supreme.

Now it is a system of autocracy where cronyism and nepotism are rife.

The government prestige and reputation has reached new lows. Just witness the following comment expressed by a FairMind on a report regarding the sudden presentation of a purported ‘note’ by the AG’s Chambers in the Teoh Beng Hock case, which I take liberty to quote:

mongolian woman bombed altantuya 081106“In Malaysia, we have the immigration department obliterating Altantuya’s (left) immigration records, the government hospital’s doctor doctoring Kugan’s post mortem record, the military covering up for the lost jet engine, the AG, PDRM and the MACC fabricating evidence for the powers-that-be, the judges acquitting the crooks and BN cronies, the customs close one eye on politicians and royalties, etc. Not only thieves and robbers are involved in dishonesty any more; in Malaysia even the government does it – yes, big time! Can we believe in the government any more?”

Belligerent tone

As a people, the Malays were becoming arrogant. Leaders like Ahmad Ismail are known to have said publicly that “If you don’t the country, just leave”. Others say something like “Don’t test our patience”, again on the principle of quick fix, albeit on a belligerent tone.

Others, many others, wave the kris menacingly in the air to dramatise and underscore their perceived grievances against the (more stable and rational) non-Malay population.

Meanwhile any and every Malay would make full use of the fact that the Malays are in control; they make full use of the might is right principle of government knowing that Big Brother is lending total support. Any and every article that smells of anti-government, anti-religion and anti-Agong sentiments would be declared ‘seditious’.

As such a police report at the very least would be made against the author. Helen Ang suffers from this case when Perkasa Youth chief Arman Azhar Abu Hanifah launched a police report against her partly for expressing anti-Agong sentiments.

NONE(But when Tun Mahathir Mohamad amended the constitution in an obvious anti-monarchy binge in 1993, well… that is ok; perhaps Perkasa was not yet around).

The imams or ulama too were becoming arrogant. They make the claim that this country is constitutionally an Islamic state (which it is not), and then force their archaic versions of Islamic values to well nigh everyone. Under this ambit suddenly S Banggarma (right), a Hindu from birth, found herself caged as a Muslim!

But at least she is still alive. Recently two unfortunate souls jumped out from the window of their respective apartments when the morality police came knocking; they were inside with their female partners. They died upon hitting ground several floors below.

The questions here are: is it justifiable for the morality police to be watchful over private morality? Are they not in some way culpable for any physical injury including death in their pursuit of upholding morality? I believe somehow that they are and at the very least an inquest should have been organised. In the event I did not detect any expression of remorse or regret on the part of the causers of these unfortunate loss of life.

NONEThe civil servants, another ‘branch’ of the Ketuanan Melayu leadership, too have their arrogance or misplaced philosophies.

Sidek Hassan (right), the chief secretary to the government said in a Malaysiakini interview that civil servants “have to be loyal” to the government of the day because “the government serves the people… the government have to be answerable to the people”.

He is absolutely correct at this point.

But he added “And if the government thinks that the best way to serve (the people) is to do it in a certain way, as civil servants we follow what the government tells us to do,” which effectively nullifies his first point.

Civil servants should stand up against any excesses shown by the government for their loyalty must always be directed to their paymasters, the people.

String of Cs

I have listed string of Cs prevailing in the country which demonstrating other symptoms of malangitis in my previous article, some of them being confusion, contradiction, conflict, and coercion in describing the social political and economic environment.

In this current writing consider this following case to illustrate two of the many Cs, confusion and contradiction, the case of the touted ‘The Government Transformation Programme’, otherwise known as ‘1Malaysia’.

Apparently the goal of 1Malaysia is “a nation where, it is hoped, every Malaysian perceives himself or herself as Malaysian first, and by race, religion, geographical region or socio-economic background second”.

It was a definition clear and concise, even a reasonable secondary schoolboy could or would understand what this means. We were all geared to internalize this worthwhile mission.

But when DPM Muhyiddin Yasin was asked about his stand on this vital issue he insisted that he is ‘Malay first’! He continued with by now famous “How can I say I’m Malaysian first and Malay second? All the Malays will shun me… and it’s not proper.”

NONEThen take the case of the august YB Mustapa Mohamed (right) speaking at a press conference on Aug 7 after opening a 10th Malaysia Plan seminar at a hotel in Kuala Lumpur.

Apparently he mentioned that the people, especially Malays, should not disregard the NEP because it has brought about “many achievements” since its inception in 1971. It breaks my heart when I hear that Malays say they don’t need the NEP,” he apparently said further.

He cleverly did not say that many Malays are essentially tired not of the original principles and visions of NEP but on the inability to respond adequately psychologically to the changing demands, to the subsequent abuse of its implementation (like nepotism), and to the endemic corruption it has brought along.

Affirmative action

Mustapa then talked about the non-bumiputeras having to accept the reality that Malays have rights to affirmative action, that the dignity, pride and honour of the Malay must be protected.

A series of confusion immediately here for he mentioned two famous words – rights and reality. Rights and reality? What rights and what reality?

Is it the right to steal and plunder the nation’s treasury? Or to smash into pieces public institutions like education (and producing graduates who could not interact) and the judiciary (where we revert to tribal laws)?

Or, fragmenting of the people into bumis and non-bumis, filthy rich and dirt poor Malays, Muslims and non-Muslims? Between open-minded freedom-loving and close-minded mentally enslaved citizens?

jalur gemilang 090905Or, FDI to dwindle by 89 percent in 2009 alone and with Mustapa saying not to worry, this is ok? Or, the running away of domestic capital abroad? Or the more than 300,000 talented, experienced, knowledgeable and trained people running away to other climes in the last two years? Are these the rights and reality Mustapa mentioned in the pursuit and preservation of Malay dignity and honour?

Hang Tuah wouldn’t agree to this, nor would Tun Abdul Razak, or the ordinary well-meaning but manipulated Malay mainstream.

In the meantime my acute malangitis prevents me from planting the jalur gemilang come this August 31st.

 

//

 

AB SULAIMAN is an observer of human traits and foibles, especially within the context of religion and culture. As a liberal, he marvels at the way orthodoxy fights to maintain its credibility in a devilishly fast-changing world. He hopes to provide some understanding to the issues at hand and wherever possible, suggest some solutions. He holds a Bachelor in Social Sciences (Leicester, UK) and a Diploma in Public Administration, Universiti Malaya.

 

I was stuck in a traffic jam on the LDP last week. Nothing moved for half an hour when suddenly a man knocks on my window. So I roll down my window and ask, “What’s going on?”

”Terrorists down the road have kidnapped  a few UMNO politicians. They’re asking for a  RM10 million ransom or they’re going to douse them with petrol and set them on fire.  We are going from car to car, taking up a collection.”

I innocently asked, “How much is everyone giving on average..?”

“Most people are giving about a gallon”

As I have said many times before in my earlier post, we have too many little Napoleons now, created by our great NEP and Mahathir which is taking this country to doom. The below incident that occurred in a school in Kulai, JB is a clear example of what is happening in schools nowadays. These are the reasons why the non-malays are shifting away from the national schools. Racist and religious remarks are rampant in national schools. If we were to take actions on all these bigots, half the civil service have to be sacked, but of course this would not happen! Politically incorrect mah…………………..

“Pelajar-pelajar Cina tidak diperlukan dan boleh balik ke China ataupun Sekolah Foon Yew. Bagi pelajar India, tali sembahyang yang diikat di pergelangan tangan dan leher pelajar nampak seakan anjing dan hanya anjing akan mengikat seperti itu.” By Student of Sekolah Menengah Kebangsaan Tunku Abdul Rahman Putra, Kulai
 
(The Star) KULAIJAYA: Police are investigating a school principal who allegedly used racist remarks against non-Malay students during a Merdeka celebration at the school here recently.
Kulaijaya deputy OCPD Asst Supt Mohd Kamil said police had received 12 reports against the principal since Saturday and that the case was being investigated under Section 504 of the Penal Code.
Over 50 parents and students had lodged the reports against the principal, who allegedly described the non-Malays as “penumpang” (passengers) in the country during her speech at the start of the celebration on Aug 12.
“I was shocked that my principal had used such a word against non-Malay students in our school.
“This is not the first time that she had made racist comments against Chinese and Indian students in our school,” said 17-year-old student Brevia Pan.
She added that the principal, who joined the school early this year, would only target Chinese and Indian students.
“During the Merdeka celebration, she had told non-Malay students to go study in a Chinese school or go back to China,” she told reporters in a press conference organised by Senai assemblyman Ong Kow Meng.
Another student, Ashvini Thi-na­karan, 17, said many Malay students were influenced by the principal’s remarks and made similar comments and called them names.
“Before she came to my school, all the students got along well,” she said. Her father R. Thinakaran, 47, said this was a serious matter and that principals should not behave like this.
“This principal has caused racial disharmony at the school,” he said, adding that if no action was taken, he would take his daughter out of the school.
Ong called for stern action against the principal, adding that such school heads and educators would affect the minds of students.